Tavern 5: Experience Exceptional Cocktails and Cuisine in Pompton Plains

The placed was crowded but not too loud either. I saw all walks to life- families, couples, friends catching up, girls/guys night out, and so forth. The vibe was positive and they also played music. Our server was nice. She made us feel like we were her only customer. It was our first time, so she was also patient with us deciding on what to eat. Our food came out on time. Great portion, great quality and worth the price. Overall, I really enjoyed the positive energy.

Been here plenty of time. Food is always good. Service is good. Definitely get a reservation since it's almost always very busy. It can be a little loud at peak times.

Great food, good service but can get a bit too noisy at times. Great for lunch too and better than most pizza places around.

Great food and service a little pricey but worth it Great atmosphere had some nice veggie options

WOW so good!! Came for a wedding and every single bite was delicious! Absolutely loved the Caesar salad, chicken francese, short rib spring rolls... all so delicious! Dessert was also fantastic! Bread pudding was perfection - not too sweet and crisp on the outside (yum!), chocolate chip cookies were great, and the cheesecake was so fluffy with a delicious melt in your mouth graham cracker crust. Great service too and a beautiful outdoor area.

The service was very quick and the food was good! The cocktails are exceptional. Servings were portioned perfectly with their price. Pleasant ambiance for a casual dinner out! Salad was supposed to have grilled chicken but was forgotten. It was brought out immediately once it was mentioned.

I've have this restaurant book marked for some time and I am very happy I finally had the time to go. The place is very big with 3 rooms/sections. The bar area, the dining area which has a front area and a back area and then there's the covered deck area too. We sat in the covered deck and it was so cute out there. There was a fire pit in the middle of the deck and heated lamps on top, if it's too cold. For drinks, I ordered one of their seasonal drinks a Fig Martini, but as a virgin(Mocktini is what I called it). For dinner I ordered their Short Rib with Mash and season veggies. And let me tell you... the beef was so fork tender and delicious. My sister had a cheese burger and I snuck a bite or two and that was delicious too. Haven't had a burger that taste so good like that in a minute! I can't wait to come back!

Enjoyed two specials, a salad, and a meatball appetizer, which was delicious with fresh ricotta When we got there, it was quiet, but within an hour the place was full and very loud and noisy. Next time I'll sit outside in the beautiful garden they have. I ordered a espresso martini which was delicious and everyone enjoyed their food and drinks. The weight staff was very attentive, but not overbearing. Definitely will come back.